Service-Learning vs. Experiential Learning Criteria

Mon, 18 May 1998 14:55:48 -0500
Robyn Gibboney (rgibbone@WPO.IUPUI.EDU)

An article I have found to be helpful in explaining the continuum is by
Andrew Furco, "Service-Learning: A Balanced Approach to Experiential
Education," in Expanding Boundaries: Service and Learning (available
through an organization called the Community Campus Partnerships for
Health). He builds on Sigmon's typology and explores distinctions among
different kinds of experiential education as well as different kinds of
service.

Sigmon (1994):

service-LEARNING
Learning goals primary; service outcomes secondary

SERVICE-learning
Service outcomes primary; learning goals secondary

service-learning
Service and learning goals completely separate

SERVICE-LEARNING
Service and learning goals of equal weight and each enhances the other
for all participants

Furco (This table may not be clear over e-mail, but here's a try):

Recipient ---------------------BENEFICIARY-----------------Provider
Service -------------------------- FOCUS-------------------- Learning

SERVICE-LEARNING
COMMUNITY SERVICE FIELD EDUCATION
VOLUNTEERISM INTERNSHIP

Hope that helps!

Robyn Gibboney
Director of Development
Indiana University School of Nursing
1111 Middle Drive, NU 101
Indianapolis, IN 46202-5107
317-274-4293
317-274-2996 (fax)
rgibbone@wpo.iupui.edu